Markets live
Data: CoinGecko

Opinion: gold failed its safe-haven test this week, so do not chase the dip

Gold fell with stocks on Friday instead of cushioning the blow, and the forces pushing it down have not turned. Our view for Indian buyers: wait, and buy in stages if you must buy now.

Stacks of rectangular gold bars on a shelf inside a vault
Stacked 400-ounce gold bars in a vault, photographed in 2014. Photo: Andrzej Barabasz, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons, cropped.

Gold is cheaper in India than it has been all month, and the temptation to buy the dip is strong. We think buyers should hold off, because gold failed the one test it is supposed to pass: it did not protect anyone when stocks crashed. In our gold price forecast on Nov. 18 we showed how the metal had already slid to its lowest level this year, and the week since has made the case for patience stronger.

The essentials

  • India’s 22K rate was ₹11,465 a gram at 10:15 a.m. IST on Nov. 22, the lowest this month and about 15% below the month high of ₹13,534.
  • Gold fell alongside stocks on Friday, Nov. 20, when Yahoo Finance’s quote page showed it down 4.62% at $3,515.40 as the Nasdaq fell 5.3%.
  • In our opinion, buyers who can wait should wait, and anyone who must buy for a wedding or festival should buy in two or three stages instead of all at once.

Why does this fall look different?

Gold is the asset people buy when they are afraid, and it usually rises on a bad day for stocks. On Friday the Nasdaq fell 5.28% and gold fell with it. We reported earlier this week that analysts thought some of the selling was forced, with investors selling bullion to cover losses elsewhere, and American Gold Exchange analyst Jim Wyckoff said stock losses had “maybe prompted some margin calls.” That is not a safe-haven story. It is a story about people raising cash.

This matters because the case for owning gold, especially for Indian households, rests on it holding up when other things fail. A fall of this kind does not break that case for the long run. It does mean that this week gold behaved like a risky asset, and anyone buying it now as protection should know that.

How far has it fallen?

The slide has been steady, and it has sped up in November. Using the prices in our earlier reports:

DatePriceChange from record
Jan. 28 (record)About $5,589n/a
Oct. 20About $4,131Down about 26%
Nov. 12About $3,972Down about 29%
Nov. 18About $3,785Down about 32%
Nov. 20About $3,515 to $3,540Down about 37%
Gold price in US dollars per ounce, approximate, 2026. Sources: CBS News, Nowbrief live price data, GoodReturns.

In rupee terms, our indicative 22K rate fell from ₹12,722 a gram on Nov. 13 to ₹11,498 on Nov. 20, a drop of 9.6%, before today’s ₹11,465 on the GRT board. Gold is also cheaper in Dubai, where 22K was AED 396.25 a gram on Nov. 22.

What has not changed?

The reasons gold fell in the first place are still there. Futures traders saw a 94% chance of a quarter-point US rate rise in December, CNBC reported, and Fed Governor Christopher Waller said a half-point rise could be considered. The dollar index was near 104 and the 10-year Treasury yield was just above 5%, according to our report on the weekly drop. Gold pays no interest, so every one of those makes it harder to hold.

Fear has also faded. Gold surged to its record in January as people feared a US-Iran war, and progress in diplomacy has since cooled that safe-haven buying, FOREX.com analyst Fawad Razaqzada told Kitco. The war itself has not ended, as our reports from the Gulf show, but the market no longer pays a premium for the worry.

What is the best case for buying?

There is one, and we take it seriously. Gold is already about 37% below its January record, and spot gold is close to the $3,476 level that FOREX.com named as a downside target. On the estimates in our forecast, a fall to $3,476 would put 22K at about ₹11,450 a gram, almost exactly where the board is today at ₹11,465. The two figures use slightly different methods, so treat that as a rough guide, but it suggests a lot of the fall is already in the Indian price.

TD Securities, for its part, expects gold to stay near the bottom of a $3,900 to $4,200 range. A buyer who waits could miss a bounce.

Our answer is that a floor is a guess, and the cost of being early is real. Nobody knows where it is, and the December Fed meeting is a clear event risk. If the Fed raises rates by more than traders expect, the dollar could climb again and gold could slip further.

What would a 5% move cost you?

Here is what that looks like on a real purchase, so the debate has a rupee figure on it. Take one pavan (8 grams) of 22K jewellery, with 12% making charges and 3% GST, at today’s rate:

ScenarioRate per gramTotal bill
Today₹11,465About ₹1,05,808
Rate 5% lowerAbout ₹10,892About ₹1,00,518
Rate 5% higherAbout ₹12,038About ₹1,11,099
Cost of 8 g of 22K jewellery if the gold rate moves 5%. Making charges 12%, GST 3%. Nowbrief calculation from the Nov. 22 rate of ₹11,465 a gram; shop prices vary.

A 5% move changes the bill by about ₹5,300 either way. That is real money, but it is small next to the roughly ₹14,100 of making charges and GST already in the price. For many buyers, the design and the shop’s charges matter as much as the day’s rate.

What should Indian buyers do?

For jewellery, remember that a lower rate does not shrink your bill as much as it looks. At today’s 22K rate, one gram with 12% making charges and 3% GST comes to about ₹13,226 on our gold rate today in India page, so charges soften the benefit of any dip. Making charges vary by shop.

Our suggestions, which are opinion and not advice: – If you can wait, do. There is no deadline on a rate that may fall further. – If you must buy, split the purchase into two or three parts, a few weeks apart, so one bad day does not set your price. – If you already own gold, there is no reason to sell because of one week. Jewellery is not a trading position. – Do not borrow to buy gold, and do not buy a large amount in one day because the price looks low. – Ask the shop for making charges in writing and compare them, because a lower charge can save more than a good day’s rate. – Check the rate on the day. Shop boards can differ slightly from our indicative rate.

What about coins, bars and gold funds?

Everything above is about jewellery, because that is how most Indian households buy. Coins and bars are different. They carry far less in making charges, so a fall in the rate matters more to the total cost, and the case for staging purchases is the same. Our gold page notes that making charges on jewellery usually run from 8% to 25%, so compare that with the premium on a coin before you choose.

We have not looked at gold funds in this piece, and we are not recommending any product. The logic of waiting and buying in stages applies to any form of gold, but the costs, taxes and rules are different, so read the terms before you buy.

How will we review this view?

We will come back to this piece after the December Fed meeting, which is the next big test of the rate-hike story. If gold has stabilised and rate expectations have eased, we will say so and change our advice. If it has fallen further, we will say that too. An opinion is only useful if its author is willing to be checked against what happens.

What would change our view?

We will change our view if rate-hike bets fade or if gold rises on a day when stocks fall, which would show it is behaving like a haven again. A clear break back above $3,900 would also tell us the selling is over. Until then we think patience costs less than being wrong.

This is an opinion article. The views are those of the author and Nowbrief, and this article is for information only and is not investment advice. Gold rates in India change during the day, and shops add making charges and 3% GST.

Sources

Nikesh Avatar

This article is for information only and is not financial advice. Read our editorial standards and ethics policy.