Rahul Gandhi, the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha, said at the University of Chicago on Wednesday, Nov. 18, 2026, that India should keep strong strategic and defence ties with Israel but must not stay silent on Gaza, and the remarks have drawn criticism from the Congress party’s Left allies. He was speaking in a conversation titled “The Iran War and India’s Role in the World,” a conflict we have followed in our reports from the Gulf.
The essentials
- Gandhi said India should support a strong relationship with Israel, including buying weapons, but that it “cannot mean silence on Gaza,” and he condemned both the Oct. 7, 2023 Hamas attacks and Israel’s actions in Gaza.
- Pinarayi Vijayan of the CPI(M) said the remarks “expose the Congress party’s glaring hypocrisy on Palestine,” and CPI(ML) Liberation’s Dipankar Bhattacharya said there could be no strategic relationship with Israel.
- Sonia Gandhi and Priyanka Gandhi Vadra have both used the word genocide about Israel’s actions in Gaza, which Gandhi did not use, according to The Indian Panorama.
What did Rahul Gandhi say?
Gandhi told political scientist Robert Pape that India’s relationship with Israel was important but should not stop New Delhi from taking its own position, Siasat and Outlook India reported. “We have good relations with Israel, and we buy weapons from them,” he said, adding that India is a much bigger country of 1.5 billion people and its foreign policy should rest on what is good for India.
He condemned both the Oct. 7 attacks and Israel’s war in Gaza. “One wrong cannot justify another,” he wrote when he shared highlights on X, according to Varthabharati. He also said no country, whether Israel, the United States, Russia or China, should hold India back from its rightful role on the global stage.
What else did he say about India’s place in the world?
Gandhi said India had become a “side player” in global diplomacy while Pakistan was busy negotiating with Iran and the United States, according to Siasat and Varthabharati. He took an indirect shot at Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s closeness to US President Donald Trump, saying friendship is not the point and geopolitics cannot work that way.
The trip was a two-day visit to the United States, and he also spoke to students and faculty at Columbia University in New York, Siasat reported.
Who has criticised him?
| Who | Party or role | What they said |
|---|---|---|
| Pinarayi Vijayan | CPI(M), former Kerala chief minister | The remarks expose Congress’s glaring hypocrisy on Palestine, and a pro-imperialist position undermines Nehru’s legacy |
| Dipankar Bhattacharya | General secretary, CPI(ML) Liberation | No strategic relationship with a state he called genocidal |
| Apoorvanand | Delhi University professor | Said it was deeply disappointing and that you cannot fight genocidal politics at home and be friends with it abroad |
| Arfa Khanum Sherwani | Journalist | Said Gandhi talked about Oct. 7 but chose silence on what followed |
The CPI(M) is a close ally of the Congress at the Centre, The Indian Panorama noted. Maktoob reported that many social media users criticised Gandhi for calling relations with Israel “good” and for not using the word genocide.
How does it differ from Sonia and Priyanka Gandhi?
Sonia Gandhi and Priyanka Gandhi Vadra have both described Israel’s actions in Gaza as genocide. On Aug. 12, 2025, Priyanka Gandhi accused the Israeli government of genocide and called the Indian government’s silence shameful, which drew a reply from Israel’s ambassador to India, Reuven Azar, the Tribune reported. The Indian Panorama described Rahul Gandhi’s position as a moderation of the party’s stand and closer to the Modi government’s balancing of ties between Israel and the Arab world.
What has Congress said?
The Congress party shared excerpts of the remarks on its own social media, Maktoob reported. We have not seen a response from the party to the criticism by the Left parties, and we will update this article if one is reported.
This article reports statements made at a public event and on social media, and reactions to them. Quotes are as published by the outlets named. Nowbrief did not attend the event. This article is for information only.
Sources
- India must not stay silent on Gaza, says Rahul Gandhi on Israel ties (Siasat)
- What did Rahul Gandhi say about Gaza war? (Outlook India)
- Rahul Gandhi backs strong India-Israel ties, says they should not mean silence on Gaza (Varthabharati)
- Rahul breaks from Sonia, Priyanka on Israel; Left allies hit out (The Indian Panorama)
- Rahul Gandhi’s backing of “strong relationship” with Israel sparks outrage (Maktoob)
- Priyanka Gandhi accuses Israel of committing genocide in Palestine, draws ire from envoy Reuven Azar (The Tribune)




